How to Measure the ROI of Employer Branding

We’ve all heard the question: if a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?

Now try this: if your employer brand is working but you’re not measuring it, does it matter?

This is the fourth and final post in our Talent Attraction Blueprint series. If you missed the earlier entries, start with Purpose, move on to your People, then follow up with the right Platform.

After Purpose, People, and Platform comes Proof: measuring what matters so you can improve, adapt, and grow. If you missed the third post in the series on People, we explored how to build your EVP around employee truth. So you can improve, adapt, and grow.

Why Proof Matters in Employer Branding

Most employer brand efforts don’t fail because they’re bad. They fail because no one knows if they’re working.

That’s a visibility problem. And it’s one you can solve by tracking the right metrics.

Start by asking better questions:

  • Are we attracting the right people?
  • Are our hires sticking?
  • Is our message aligned with our employee experience?

When you start with curiosity instead of just KPIs, you make better decisions.

The Metrics That Matter Most

Here are six metrics we recommend to our clients. You don’t need to track all of them, but you should pick a few to start with and review them regularly.

1. Source of Hire

Where are your best candidates coming from? Referral? Job board? LinkedIn? This tells you which channels are working and where to invest.

2. Application-to-Interview Conversion

How many applicants are making it to interviews? A low rate might mean your messaging is attracting the wrong people.

3. Drop-Off Rate on Careers Page

If people are visiting your careers page but not applying, your message isn’t connecting or your process is too complex.

4. Quality of Hire (QoH)

Manager satisfaction, performance reviews, or retention at the 90-day mark often measure this.

5. Hiring Velocity

How long does it take to fill open roles? If this number is going down, something is working.

6. 90-Day Retention

This is a key signal. If people leave quickly, there’s a mismatch between brand promise and employee reality.

Proof in Action: GlobalTec

GlobalTec came to Revel struggling to compete for tech-savvy talent. They needed to stand out to candidates who were evaluating multiple options.

Revel helped them develop a clear, confident employer brand and carried that through to job posts, video, and a refreshed careers page.

The result? A measurable increase in applicant quality and a significant reduction in time to hire.

Analytics showed improved application completion rates and deeper candidate engagement. Managers reported a better fit. The data confirmed what the team felt: the brand was finally working.

From Recruitment to Retention: Long-Term Value

Strong measurement begins with strong alignment. And that means getting HR and marketing in the same room.

HR owns the people. Marketing owns the message. When they work together, your employer brand becomes more than a campaign—it becomes a consistent, credible experience.

Start with shared goals. Meet regularly. Define handoffs. And use data not just to justify spend, but to improve the process.

That kind of alignment builds a brand that attracts the right people and keeps them.

It’s easy to fall into the trap of measuring clicks, likes, or impressions. But those are just signals. The goal is to understand what’s creating meaningful results.

That means going deeper:

  • Are the people applying a fit for your values?
  • Are new hires aligning quickly with your culture?
  • Are your stories driving action?

If not, something’s off.

You Don’t Have to Guess at ROI

You don’t need to build a dashboard or hire a data scientist. Start small:

  • Review metrics monthly or quarterly
  • Tie your observations back to messaging, process, or culture
  • Use what you learn to adjust and improve

Revel calls this “Work the Results,” the W in our GROW process. It’s about turning data into action. Refining what’s working. Rethinking what isn’t. And making employer branding a habit, not a hunch.

A few minutes of focused attention beats a shelf full of unread reports.

Tie It All Back to the Employee Experience

Your employer brand makes a promise. Your metrics tell you if you’re keeping it.

And here’s the truth: retention goes up when your EVP is grounded in what employees actually experience. Culture gets stronger. And talent starts finding you instead of the other way around.

Because when you brand your culture with purpose and back it with proof, it works.

Get a Clearer Picture of What Your Employer Brand Is Really Delivering

This wraps up our four-part Talent Attraction Blueprint series. We’ve covered Purpose, People, Platform, and Proof — the foundation for a stronger, smarter approach to attracting and keeping the right people.

Alignment isn’t just important between HR and marketing. It’s essential across the leadership team. When HR, marketing, and executive decision-makers, including the CEO, CFO, and other top leaders, are aligned, employer branding becomes a strategic advantage, not just a tactical effort. It drives business outcomes: better hires, stronger retention, and greater clarity about who you are and what you stand for.

If you’ve followed the series and are ready to put the pieces into action, we’d love to help you see what’s working, what’s missing, and where you can grow next.

At Revel, we help HR leaders bring clarity and consistency to employer branding. That includes:

  • Employer Touch Point Audit
  • Employee Insights
  • Candidate Personas
  • Employer Value Proposition (EVP)
  • Campaign Messaging 
  • Brand Activation Strategy
  • Careers Page Update
  • Recruitment Campaigns featuring Culture Videos, Original Photography, Employee Newsletters, Internal Collateral, Targeted Social Media Advertising, Billboards, and more

Request a Free Employer Brand Audit

Jason is a Partner and the CEO at Revel, a B2B marketing agency. He is a diehard baseball fan who loves his Detroit Tigers. Family vacations often revolve around seeing games in different MLB ballparks around the country – they’ve been to 21 so far and counting. Connect with him on LinkedIn or Twitter.

Related Posts

The Story Behind Watch Muskegon

A look back on 10 years of Watch Muskegon. Sometimes the biggest ideas start small. That’s exactly what happened with Watch Muskegon. But to really ...
Read More

Where Your Employer Brand Shows Up Matters: Visibility Is Everything for Candidate Experience

It’s one thing to define who you are as an employer. It’s another to show up in the right places so the right people see ...
Read More
Abstract social network background with people icons connected b

How Real Employee Stories Shape a Strong Employer Branding Strategy

There was a time when foosball tables and happy hours were the calling cards of company culture. But today’s candidates are asking bigger questions. Do ...
Read More
Scroll to Top